2021
- Adah Beatrice
- Carly Bornstein-Hayward
- Elizabeth Buege
- Jeni Chappelle
- Miranda Darrow
- Tiffany Grimes
- Natasha Hanova
- Bethany Hensel
- Felice Laverne
- Katie McCoach
- Kyra Nelson
- Leah Pierre
- Michelle Rascon
- Megan Records
- Heidi Shoham
- Maria Tureaud
- Hannah VanVels
- Jay Whistler
- Tyler Zeoli
- Nicole Frail (runners-up prizes)
- Tiffany White (runners-up prizes)
2020
- Carly Bornstein-Hayward
- Elizabeth Buege
- Jeni Chappelle
- Tera Cuskaden
- Miranda Darrow
- Tiffany Grimes
- Natasha Hanova
- Bethany Hensel
- Holly Ingraham
- Megan Manzano
- Katie McCoach
- Kyra Nelson
- Michelle Rascon
- Megan Records
- Heidi Shoham
- Maria Tureaud
- Hannah VanVels
- rr campbell (runners-up prizes)
- Stephanie Eding (runners-up prizes)
2019
- Sione Aeschliman
- Carly Bornstein-Hayward
- Editor Cassandra
- Elizabeth Buege
- rr campbell
- Jeni Chappelle
- Tera Cuskaden
- Kyle V. Hiller
- Holly Ingraham
- Katie McCoach
- Kyra Nelson
- Michelle Rascon
- Maria Tureaud
- Jay Whistler
- Tiffany White
- Stephanie Eding (runners-up prizes)
- Kaitlyn Johnson (runners-up prizes)
2018
- Sione Aeschliman
- Carly Bornstein-Hayward
- Ellen Brock
- Editor Cassandra
- Elizabeth Buege
- rr campbell
- Jeni Chappelle
- Stephanie Eding
- Kyle V. Hiller
- Kaitlyn Johnson
- Katie McCoach
- Laura Dennison (runners-up prizes)
- Grace Laidlaw (runners-up prizes)
- Kyra Nelson (runners-up prizes)
2017
- Sione Aeschliman
- Gem Blackthorn
- Carly Bornstein-Hayward
- Ellen Brock
- Editor Cassandra
- Elizabeth Buege
- Jeni Chappelle
- Stephanie Eding
- Victoria Griffin
- Kaitlyn Johnson
- Katie McCoach
- Nicole Tone
- Kisa Whipkey
- Kyra Nelson (runners-up prizes)
